I am as you are all probably aware a big fan of Elizabeth von Arnin and of course a big Persephone fan so a book combining the two felt like a real treat. This wonderful Elizabeth von Arnim novel was out of print for decades before Persephone brought it back. I can’t understand why it was out of print so long, perhaps the rather unexciting title is partly responsible. For me, Expiation felt like classic von Arnim.
This is a novel full to the brim of Elizabeth von Arnim’s delicious wit, a satirically humorous novel about middle class prudery and close-minded cruelty. Everything about this novel is perfect – each scene, each piece of dialogue is simply superb. Even the name chosen for our heroine’s in-laws is perfect – Bott – a word that can be spat out in exasperation and disgust as poor Milly might long to do. Oh, those Botts!
“That important south London suburb appreciated the Botts, so financially sound, so continually increasing in prosperity. They were its backbone. They subscribed, presided, spoke, ordered. Titford was full of Botts, and every one of them a credit to it.”
As the novel opens Milly Bott is surrounded by her sorrowing in-laws – her husband died in a road accident a few days earlier, they have buried him and the solicitor is about to read the will. Everyone adores Milly, in her forties, she is soft and comforting and good – and never gave poor Ernest a moments trouble. Though the couple remained childless she was a good wife to Ernest. The Bott clan is a large one, an elderly mother-in-law and several sons and daughters each with their own wives and husbands and offspring. These people are drawn so well – they are hilariously infuriating, and while Milly may have committed adultery, our sympathies are one hundred per cent with her. There is something very lovable about Milly – perhaps because she isn’t perfect, and the Botts are so insufferable, pompous and rather absurd. We know how well von Arnim writes such absurd creatures, her portrayal of them is always wincingly accurate.
In the polite suburb of Titford the Bott family are well known and well thought off – the Botts are suitably proud of their position. They are respectable in every way – and consider themselves the leading lights of behaviour and morality. However, the Botts are about to be shaken to the core. When the will is read, it is revealed that Ernest has left all his money to a charity for ‘fallen women’ – adding the dark rejoinder that his wife will know why. Milly will have just a £1000 of his large estate for herself. Speculation is immediate and not kind – by page 29 the reader knows that the Bott speculation is pretty spot on.
“It had begun quite by chance. And what a chance, thought Milly, looking back now with the horrified clear vision which is the portion of the found out, at the beginning. Such small things had made it begin. Five minutes earlier, five minutes later, and she never would have met Arthur. A missed train, a slower taxi, even just a pause to watch the pigeons in the courtyard, or, indeed, even a little decent reserve, and she would have been saved. But the train was caught, the taxi was swift, the pigeons didn’t interest her, and in she went; and there, in the British Museum, in the gallery where the busts of the Roman emperors are, she met Arthur Oswestry, and they sinned.”
For ten years Milly had been having an affair with a man she met in The British Museum – and now she realises, due to the date of the will, that Ernest had known for the last two. For readers of a novel first published in 1929, this was far more shocking than it would be today.
The novel is the story of Milly’s attempt at expiation, at atonement for her great sin. This involves her deciding to escape the Botts by fleeing to her sister who many years earlier disgraced the family – and who Ernest had barred Milly from contacting – yet in a wonderful bit of past defiance had continued to write to. Only, things don’t quite work out as Milly had planned. We follow Milly as she encounters the harsh world of disapproval in the guise of her sister changed by circumstance, a nosy landlady and the sneering, family lawyer. She even feels unworthy of her £1000, and the deep black of mourning that she is wearing. Poor Milly wears her shame heavily and is horribly hard on herself. In time Milly must make her way back to Titford – and the world of the Botts – submitting meekly to their plans for her.
Anyone worrying that this will all be horribly bleak and sad, fear not – in Elizabeth von Arnim’s hands it is anything but. Ultimately this is marvellously uplifting – and I defy anyone not to fall in love with dear Milly.
I hope that final paragraph means that things work out well for Milly!
Well I don’t want to give any spoilers, but we certainly aren’t cast down by her apparent fate.
This will be fun to read. The Botts sound like awful people – your worst nightmare.
The Botts are awful, Milly is far politer to them than I would manage to be.
Another gem from Von Arnim and a beautiful Persephone as well, excellent! I love how Von Arnim creates reader sympathy for characters that might have been harshly judged in their time, her distance from convention in real life gave her pen an incredible freedom to do as it liked without caring the opinion of others.
Oh yes, Elizabeth von Arnim was hardly conventional herself. So was perfectly placed to write about the absurd judgements of others no doubt.
Now I must find my copy that Husband bought for me.. a very enticing review!
Glad you have this to look forward to. It’s such an enjoyable novel.
Those quotes are fantastic Ali, I love the sound of this!
Elizabeth von Arnim has such a great turn of phrase. Glad you like the sound of this one.
I haven’t read any Elizabeth von Arnim yet and this sounds wonderful, the Botts and Titford sound absolutely ghastly!
I highly recommend Elizabeth von Arnim, I have never read anything by her I didn’t love. The Botts and Titford were brilliantly awful.
Wonderful! If I didn’t already have an unread EvA on my pile, I would be dashing out (aka emailing the bookshop) to buy it in a flash. It sounds marvellous. She really is a very clever writer, particularly when it comes to conveying these infuriating (or insufferable) characters…
Definitely one for the future then, it’s joyous in its own way. EvA portrays these sorts of characters so well it’s delicious.
Sounds marvellous, and the Botts sound dreadful. As Jacqui says, EvA writes awful characters so well (Otto in The Caravaners!!)
Oh yes Otto, the Botts aren’t quite as bad as him, but certainly in the same ball park.
von Arnim is such a consistently good writer. I’ve just read and enjoyed Father and am looking forward to reading Expiation.
Father is such a wonderful novel too, I read it a few months ago. I think you will love Expiation too.
What a gorgeous photo. And I’m a big EvA fan, so this is one I definitely want to read!
It’s so good, I hope you enjoy it.
I loved this – review coming out on Thursday. The Botts were deliciously awful and it had a lot to say, didn’t it, in addition to being a page-turner – my heart was in my mouth at some points!
[…] my birthday 2020 books, this one from Ali, who has also read this fairly recently (read her review here), and by an author by whom I’ve read a fair few books over the years. Von Arnim is always […]
[…] Heavenali’s blog delights in the absurdity of the Botts, in February 2021. […]