(Two of my titles are missing from the pictured pile, one was read on my kindle, one I borrowed so don’t have a copy of)
It’s always difficult to sum up an entire year in one blog post. I’m going to pointedly ignore all other external things and just talk books.
Of course, 2016 was the year of my #Woolfalong and that turned out to be a thoroughly illuminating reading experience. I was tempted to put three or four of my Virginia Woolf reads on my best of list … but instead I have stuck to my usual rules. No re-reads, and only one title per author. How to judge one book against another? You can’t and I haven’t – my choices are purely based on the what they meant to me, some of my choices are obviously literary – others perhaps less so – but I just loved them. At the end of the day that’s the only way I can judge. All but one of my choices are fiction – though three non-fiction books were in contention, only one made the final list – as fiction is my first love eleven works of fiction seem about right. So here they are: eight novels, three collections of short stories and one superb essay collection. Typically, only two of my choices were published in 2016. (Clicking on the title of each book will take you to my original review).
In alphabetical order.
Death Comes for the Archbishop – Willa Cather (1927)
My favourite Cather novel is A Lost Lady, but I didn’t read that this year, and Death Comes for the Archbishop comes only just behind that beautiful book now. I had had it on my shelf for ages, the premise didn’t particularly appeal – oh how wrong I was. I was captivated by the landscape, the story of a friendship – perhaps unlike any other I have read. It was a book which totally took me over, and I found myself thinking of it a lot after I had finished.
Don’t look now (short stories) – Daphne Du Maurier (1971)
I love short stories, and every story in this collection is brilliant– five long short stories, that are brilliantly fleshed out and satisfying. For sheer readability and tension – this collection is superb – I was sorry to finish it.
How to be a Heroine (essays) – Samantha Ellis (2014)
This is a book about books, it is also a work of feminism, literary criticism and memoir. I enjoyed meeting up with my own literary heroines, and encountering new ones or ones I had forgotten about. This was a book chosen by my very small book group, I loved our discussion of it, I had borrowed my friend’s copy to read, so I will now, certainly be buying my own edition to keep.
My Name is Leon – Kit De Waal (2016)
This was that rare thing – a book that made me cry. Created by Birmingham author Kit de Waal – who I was lucky enough hear speak alongside the brilliant Jackie Kay at the Birmingham literature festival. Leon is one of the most unforgettable child characters I have met in a while. Set in the 1980s – this is a story about love, identity and family, it explores the bond which exists between siblings and reminds us how home may not always be where you expect.
Night and Day – Virginia Woolf (1919)
In a way, this novel stands for all my Woolf reading in 2016. To the Lighthouse and Mrs Dalloway were re-reads, and I loved them hugely, but I hadn’t expected much of this one. I don’t think I had ever read a review of it or heard people talk about it much. I loved the fact it was more conventional – for me it is a kind of perfect English novel, and one which has stayed with me.
Princes in the Land – Joanna Cannan (1938)
A title I had been aware of for a long time, yet had overlooked – one review I read of it somewhere made me give it a try. It is now firmly one of my favourite Persephone books. I can’t think why I managed to overlook it so long. An exquisite examination of family life that shows with brilliant honesty and some poignancy that parents can’t live their children’s lives for them. Another of those books that was over too soon.
Sandlands (short stories) – Rosie Thornton (2016)
Another collection of short stories, and an author that was new to me. Sandlands is a collection of stories very much rooted in the Suffolk countryside, among its people, villages and wildlife. The images these stories evoke will live and linger long in my mind. A white doe, appearing suddenly in the dark woods, blue winged butterflies, a barn owl watching over a decades old Oxo tin of love letters, bell ringers, the spirits which exist within a four-hundred-year old house. Rosy Thornton celebrates the flora and fauna of the county she must dearly love, the stories link subtly by landscape, and by the past and present which weaves in and out of these wonderful stories.
So Long, See you tomorrow – William Maxwell (1980)
Although not published till 1980, Maxwell wrote this beautifully poignant novel in the 1930s – it is utterly perfect. The novel concerns a murder, a suicide, an adulterous relationship, and the loneliness of two boys who come together briefly in the midst of a series of terrible events.
The Door – Magda Szabó – (1987)
I don’t read enough Women in translation, this book showed me that I should read more. Magda Szabo hasn’t published that many books in English, so I am saving the other I have Iza’s Ballad, hoping it is as wonderful as this. The Door is the story of ‘the lady writer’ and the long and stormy relationship with her housekeeper Emerence.
The Little Girls – Elizabeth Bowen – (1964)
Elizabeth Bowen would definitely take one of the top spots in my favourite author list. I loved The Little Girls because it is about the reunion of three friends in their sixties, it is funny, moving and exquisitely written. I could easily imagine it as a film – I really think it should be a film. It isn’t an easy read – but it more than rewards the attention it requires. The Little Girls is a novel about the past, ageing and friendship, it is about those things that we bury and how we carry them with us. There is a wonderful atmosphere to this novel. I read a tatty old paperback copy of this, suffering a very heavy cold while on holiday in my favourite Devon town, a few weeks later I found a much nicer hardback copy and snapped it up.
The Winged Horse – Pamela Frankau (1953)
Pamela Frankau is the author of one of my favourite ever Virago books – The Willow Cabin – The Winged Horse is very nearly as good as that one. Set in both England and America it is a brilliantly compelling novel of power, truth and dishonesty. Pamela Frankau is someone I will be reading much more in the coming year.
The Woman Novelist & other stories (short stories) – Diana Gardner (2006)
My third short story collection, and another offering from Persephone. Diana Gardner lived near to Virginia and Leonard Woolf during the second world war, sadly she published very little, a novel by her that I want very much is almost impossible to find. I need to know if it’s worth spending nearly £20 on. Many of these stories were originally published in the 1940s, but this collection, adapted from that earlier collection, was put together by Persephone, and it is superb. I loved how Diana Gardner sometimes leads us down the garden path – we think we know where we’re going – but in fact we don’t. Her writing is subtle, clever and wonderfully atmospheric.
So, that’s it – twelve books for twelve months. What’s on your list?
(A picture of my happy place)
A really lovely selection, Ali. It’s been a while since I read any du Maurier, but I’d like to get back to her next year. Maybe the short stories would be a good choice. Also very interested in the Cather and Bowen’s The Little Girls (well, Bowen in general). The Frankau sounds wonderful too, as does the Cannan. Many thanks for introducing me to some of these ‘forgotten’ authors – I love how you bring us these gems from the past. Best wishes for 2017.
Thank you Jacqui. I would love for you to discover Bowen, Cather and Pamela Frankau for yourself.
A wonderful dozen. Night and Day is the only fiction of Virginia Woolf I haven’t read yet, so I’m glad yo see you enjoyed it so much. I finally want to read Willa Cather next year. The essay collection sounds very good too.
I hope you enjoy reading Willa Cather. She’s a favourite with me.
A lovely list Ali, and it *is* so hard to pick favourites, isn’t it? I’m so pleased you like the Diana Gardner – I loved it too, and like you I’d love to know whether it’s worth tracking down her novel – it’s not cheap, is it? Maybe Persephone should reprint that one too!
Oh yes that would be marvellous. Maybe I should just take a chance on it. 😊 I ‘ll see if the one copy I found online is still there later.
A wonderful list of favourites for the year Ali and beautifully summarised, you have a wonderful instinct for the kind of novel that appeals to you and now an even greater collection of authors who will meet that, I love your Willa Cather reviews and so wish to read one, she feels so familiar already because of your reviews. Princes in the Land sounds poignant indeed, another great find from Persephone. I enjoyed reading The Door this year too and hope to read Iza’s Ballad this year, which I’ve already lent to a friend who said she liked it even more.
I’m looking forward to more great reads in 2017 and to reading your reviews as you uncover more literary gems for us.
Oh great glad you enjoyed The Door too. Hope you enjoy reading Willa Cather too soon.
I’m so happy that I have found several bookish blogs to read this year, because even if my taste in reading is completely different ( The only one of your list I’ve read is Sandlands) it is so good to find people who love books and reading as much as I do.
My tastes vary between old stuff and more recently published books. Glad you found your way here. I’m enjoying your posts too – though commenting is so much harder with blog spot.
The Willow Cabin is definitely going on my list of books to read in 2017.
Oh good! Please let me know what you think of it.
A lovely selection of books – sadly I haven’t read any of them myself, however I do have a copy Sandlands which I am looking forward to reading; even more so now I know it is one of your favourites for the year 🙂
I really hope you like Sandlands as much as I did. Happy reading in 2017.
Thank you Ali 🙂
Great choices. I enjoyed Sandlands this year too. I haven’t read many of the others on your list, but there are some that I’m hoping to read soon, particularly Death Comes for the Archbishop and Don’t Look Now – I’ve read some of du Maurier’s other short story collections but not that one.
Death comes for the Archbishop and Don’t Look Now would be great choices for the New Year. Enjoy.
I love Willa Cather’s books and Death Comes to the Archbishop is one my Classics Club Reading Challenge list for 2017, so looking forward to that one.
Lovely to see so many people planning on reading Willa Cather. Enjoy your reading.
What a lovely set of books. I’m looking forward to continuing my Willa Cather re-reads next year and reading more of Pamela Frankau, including ‘The Winged Horse’.
I hope that 2017 will bring you more great books!
I think you will love The Winged Horse. Pamela Frankau writes such great characters.
I also picked Sandlands as a book of the year. I’m glad someone else liked it as much as I did. I’ve enjoyed Rosie’s other books, too!
I thought it was such a lovely collection. I should look out for other things by Rosie Thornton.
Good choices. I too loved Willa Cather’s Death Comes for the Archbishop. Daphne du Maurier’s Don’t Look Now and Rosy Thornton’s Sandlands. Happy New Year!
Thank you, happy new year to you too.
I’ve only read one on your list, Leon, and must admit it didn’t grab me. I’m starting to think that I missed something in this book because I have seen it on lots of ‘Best of 2016’ lists!
Hope there are many more wonderful books coming your way in 2017.
We can’t all love exactly the same things can we – I thought Leon was such a heartbreaking little character and there was a real honesty to the story of those boys. Hope your 2017 reading is excellent too.
What a wonderful selection! I only had one book published in 2016 on my pile! Happy New Year and wishing you a happy reading year for 2017.
Thank you and the same to you 😊
Just twelve! That must have been hard. That’s a Cather I haven’t read yet, but as I loved A Lost Lady too, I’m extra keen on the idea now. And I have really enjoyed all the Rosy Thornton books I’ve read; I just like “her way” and I’m not sure I would care what she was writing about because even the ones with a premise that seemed a little light have ended up wholly satisfying (often rather suprisingly). Hope you have lots of lovely new favourites around the corner in 2017!
Yes, picking twelve was hard. I’m glad you said that about Rosy Thornton because I did look up a couple of her novels and was disappointed at the sound of them. They sounded overly light, and the covers rather put me off too. Hope 2017 is a good reading year for you too.
A brilliant list, Ali – some really lovely choices. And it’s got me even more excited to try Pamela Frankau this year – probably The Willow Cabin, as you recommended on my ‘tell me what to read’ post.
Oh I would love to know what you think of The Willow Cabin.
Great list! I love Bowen and Frankau and thoroughly enjoyed reading about your others, too.
Thank you, hopefully I will read more by both Frankau and Bowen this year.
I remember your review of the Willa Cather. That’s one I’ll read. (but when??? can I decide that each day has extra hours to read? 🙂 )
Feeling your pain. I feel the same most days.