Translated from the Icelandic by Brian Fitzgibbon
There are several books I read toward the end of 2022 that I would like to review properly, though I don’t think I will be able to manage that. Animal Life by Auður Ava Ólafsdóttir was in fact my final read of 2022 and probably not a book I would have reviewed had I not been reading it for Annabel’s Nordic Finds reading event.
This is the most recent novel by the author of Butterflies in November, which I really enjoyed a couple of years ago. Telling the stories of a family of midwives it also includes many thought-provoking musings on birth, death, human beings, the natural world and even the universe beyond. There is little in the way of plot, and I was left not really sure what my feelings about it were.
Set in Reykjavik in the days leading up to Christmas, as a great storm approaches the city, we meet Dómhildur, who has just delivered her 1,922nd baby.
“In order to be able to die, a human first has to be born.”
Dómhildur, is a midwife, who comes from a family of midwives and undertakers. One of these former midwives was the woman she calls her grandaunt (I would assume that was Great-Aunt in English, but it doesn’t really matter). The grandaunt now deceased is a woman long remembered at the hospital, for her unconventional methods.
“It is almost noon when the Artic night finally begins to dissolve and the ball of fire rises over the horizon, or just about, a pink streak piercing through a slit in the curtains of the delivery room, barely wider than a pocket comb, landing on the suffering woman on the bed.”
Dómhildur is living in her grandaunt’s old apartment, nothing has been done to update the furnishings or décor, it has the look and feel of somewhere an elderly person has recently vacated. The aunt’s possessions are still in the apartment, as are the manuscripts the aunt worked on for many years and the letters she received from her pen-pal in Wales.
When she isn’t at work, Dómhildur, begins to go through the mass of writings left behind by her grandaunt. She discovers three manuscripts that are rather chaotic and jumbled but which point to a near obsession in their writer. The natural world, animal life and its connection to human life, the aunt has spent years compiling and analysing information about a host of subjects, from light, to environmentalism, to the life span of an oak tree and everything in between and beyond – musings on the comparisons between animals and humans and the coincidences which need to be present for a human child ever to be created and born. Alongside the manuscripts are forty years’ worth of letters she exchanged with her pen-pal.
“I wake up on the shortest day of the year into the longest night of time. It will be a long time before the light dissolves the night and the world takes on a form.”
Light and dark is important, perhaps not surprisingly. It is the darkest time of the year in Iceland, and as Christmas draws nearer and the forecast storm gets ever closer Dómhildur meets her new temporary neighbour. An Australian tourist is staying in the apartment on the floor above, her other frequent contacts are her sister, and an electrician – who doesn’t like the dark. Dómhildur’s sister is a meteorologist with concerns about the coming storm, she phones often to ask where her sister is and what she is doing. The electrician comes to fix some lights, he is the husband of a woman whose baby Dómhildur delivered.
So, that feels like pretty much all that happens. The novel is beautifully written, there’s plenty of thought-provoking ideas within it too, but the author never allows it to get too dry or serious, providing moments of lightness too. There is a slightly fragmentary nature to this narrative, which can be harder to engage with, I was left feeling a little underwhelmed.
I read a similarly ambivalent review several weeks ago. I had planned to read it having enjoyed Butterflies so much but I’m not so sure now.
I so enjoyed Butterflies in November, perhaps I would have been better with one of her other novels.
It’s a shame this was a bit underwhelming but I can see why. I really enjoyed three of her novels previously so I think I’d still like to give this a try.
I hope you enjoy it. I should perhaps have chosen one of her other books . Never mind.
I have this to read. I shall have to wait until I’m in the mood for it I think.
I don’t want to put people off. You might like it and it’s not unenjoyable. There’s some lovely writing to be appreciated.
It was rather fragmentary wasn’t it, and although I enjoyed the writing for the most part, it lacked drive for the most part and it was only towards the end that things moved – a little! Thank you for joining in #NordicFINDS23 though, much appreciated.
It did lack drive, I agree. I think the writing was lovely, but there were definitely things missing somewhere for me.
What a pity this didn’t quite live up to expectations, especially given your response to Butterflies in November. Still, some good writing and interesting themes there, even if it lacked some forward momentum…
The writing was good, and there are some interesting ideas, but it definitely lacked momentum. It’s a shame it didn’t work better for me.
Sounds curious, Ali. I don’t mind a beautifully written book with little plot, but I do need to feel I’ve got something out of it, if you see what I mean., And it does sound as if this was missing from this book!
I think that’s right, I was left feeling rather flat, like I was missing something. It should have worked better.
Shame this wasn’t as good as you hoped. I have Butterflies on my Kindle so might have to dig it out to read for Annabel’s Nordic Finds.
I really enjoyed Butterflies, so I hope you do. Would definitely recommend it more than this one. There’s a quirkiness about Butterflies I really enjoyed.
Good review. I think I might like this one. I DNFed Miss Iceland.
Oh good I hope so. I haven’t read Miss Iceland.
Hm, that’s a shame, Butterflies and Miss Iceland were a lot more plot-driven so maybe she was experimenting. I probably will read this for the Icelandic aspect, but I fear I will find it as you did!
I will be interested in your take on it. There are some very interesting ideas within the novel and it’s well written. I wish I had read one of her other novels though really.
Miss Iceland was good but had a sad bit about a cat in it, I will read this one at some point I’m sure!
Oh no. I read a book recently by William Trevor which had a terrible thing with a cat. 😕