Thank you to the British Library and Virago for providing copies of these.
I’m back from a lovely couple of days spent with the family over Christmas – and I hope you all had a good, restive period too. I didn’t go away, but stayed at home, visiting my family on Christmas day and Boxing day – and that proved to be a really nice and stress free.
I am reviewing very slightly out of order now; I feel very behind this month anyway. However, both of these books seemed just right for the festive period although only one of them is strictly speaking a Christmas book.
Murder After Christmas – Rupert Latimer (1944)
Murder After Christmas by Rupert Latimer – looked like the perfect book to settle in with, a couple of weekends before Christmas. It certainly has all the requirements of a cracking good festive mystery. A cantankerous wealthy old man arrives to spend Christmas, there is lots of snow, and a lot of jokes about how easy it would be to murder said guest. There are also some complex family relationships, a few secrets, a redrafted will, some poison, and a lot of humour. There is surprisingly little mention of the war, for a book published in 1944 – but I can see how people at the time might want an escape from the reality of life.
Old Uncle Willie has come to stay with the Redpath family for Christmas. He is very cantankerous and enjoys being so. He has a colourful past, and is of such interest to people that the Redpaths can expect lots of visitors all wanting to get a look at the old rascal. Aside from the expected visitors Rhoda and Frank Redpath who throughout the war have shared their home with Frank’s aunt Paulina are expecting their adult son John and his fiancé Margery home for Christmas. There is a big party planned for boxing day and lots of parcels piled up on the hall table – plenty of opportunity for a murderer to strike.
So, when poor old Uncle Willie is found dead in the snow, wearing his Santa costume there are a lot of questions to be answered. It appears that the old man was poisoned by his favourite chocolates, or was their something sinister in the mince pies that were later found concealed rather oddly in his room?
“A war’s on and a murder has been committed – and we sit here talking nonsense about almond whirls and mince pies.!”
The mystery is investigated by two very senior policemen – Superintendent Cully and the Chief Constable Major Smythe who knew the dead man slightly and was at the party at the Redpaths house the night before the body was found.
There’s a lot of figuring out who precisely had a motive – who benefitted from the will, who knew about the will etc. All this is satisfyingly complex – and I did find the solution to be very clever – I definitely didn’t guess.
However, something about this one didn’t quite hit the spot with me. I feel it’s a little long, and rather repetitive – the story really could have been a lot tighter. Still, if you really like your festive whodunnits, this one is another for the pile.
The Amazing Mr Blunden – Antonia Barber (1969)
Lovely Virago sent me this book in early December with some festive chocolate – and although I generally don’t read children’s fiction – unless it’s lout oud to actual children – I knew I really wanted to dive in. The Amazing Mr Blunden has been re-titled and reissued to tie in with a new film arriving on Sky soon I believe. This book for older children was originally published in 1969 under the title Ghosts – but as I can confirm is just as likely to be enjoyed by adults too.
It is described on the back cover as an enthralling ghost story with a time travelling twist. Now, I do think there is something about ghost stories that make them perfect reading for Christmas time.
Siblings Lucy and Jamie first meet Mr Blunden at their home in London, when he calls unexpectedly to offer their mother a job as caretaker to a large empty house in the country. The job offer is a lifeline to their mother, newly widowed and with two growing children and a young baby life has clearly been hard since her husband died. Before he leaves though Mr Blunden has a quiet word with the children.
“‘When you come to the house, you will hear strange tales. They will tell you in the village that it is haunted, but you must not be afraid. When the time comes… you will know what to do.’”
Settled happily in the country, Jamie and Lucy – wonder about the words of the strange old man. Soon though they meet the ghosts he was talking about – Sara and Georgie from a hundred years earlier. They urgently need help, and explain to the children about the wheel of time – and how they can actually help to change what happens to them. Jamie and his sister will have to be very brave and undertake to travel back to Sara and Georgie’s time – to a house ruled over by the sinister Mrs Wickens who plots against them and often locks Georgie in the cellar.
Lucy and Jamie want to help the children from the past – but after exploring the local graveyard and asking an old gravedigger about the people buried there – they hear the stories of the old house that are well known in the area. Can they really change what has already happened? There is a lot for them to try and understand – and in the end they must simply trust in what Mr Blunden has told them – and believe in what they are doing.
I don’t want to say too much about the plot – it’s a lovely story of ghostly time travel and friendship. There is a delightful twist at the end too. I must say I spent a very pleasant day with this one last week – just what I needed at the time.
Hurrah! So glad you enjoyed Mr. Blunden, and I love the old film adaptation of it – so much so that I have avoided the modern adaptation… Tend to agree with your about the Latimer, as you know – my post is going up tomorrow I think, and whilst I enjoyed it, I definitely agree it could have been pruned a little!
Ah yes, Mr Blunden was lovely, just what I needed. It was a shame about Murder After Christmas, it was still enjoyable but not my favourite.
Ohh, sorry to see the Latimer didn’t work completely; the festive cover (and title) were piquing my interest but at least the atmosphere sounds well done.
I didn’t know Mr Blunden but it sounds a lovely story; the cover is reminding me of the vintage ed of I Capture a Castle. One I’m definitely looking up.
Yes the atmosphere in the Latimer was great, it should have been better than it was really. Mr Blunden cheered me up, it was a lovely story.
Mr Blunden sounds excellent, a real proper classic. A shame about the other one not quite hitting the spot – you have read a lot of classic crime so I expect you have a very good critical eye on it by now!
Mr Blunden was excellent, I can see lots of readers old and young being charmed by it. I’m not quite the golden age expert, but I have read a lot, and as a reader you know when a book just doesn’t completely satisfy.
Love the sound of Mr Blunden, which I know through the Lionel Jeffries film. It really does seem like a great read for the season. A little bit spooky, a little bit heartwarming, a little bit magical – we could all do with something like this, given the stresses of the past year.
I must admit, I hadn’t heard of the book or the old film version before I received it. Still it was a charming little read, perfect for a busy, tired day last week. We definitely all need books like that from time to time.
I also read a festive GA mystery over Christmas and although it was an entirely different book to yours my experience was very similar! I felt it could have been pruned by about a third.
Mr Blunden sounds a fun read – I only know the old film, which I haven’t seen for ages.
It’s frustrating when we end up a bit disappointed.
Mr Blunden was great fun, he clearly completely passed me by back in the day.
Well it seems obvious to me that it didn’t hit the spot because you read it BEFORE Christmas! 🙂
Ha, well I don’t think that was the problem. 😉