With thanks to the British Library for the advance copy
Many of us I think discovered Diana Tutton only because of Simon at stuck in a book’s infectious enthusiasm for a book called Guard Your Daughters – cue everyone trying to get hold of copies. Fast forward a few years, and that has been reissued by Persephone books, and now we can read Simon’s afterword in a new edition of Diana Tutton’s Mamma. Of course, Mamma has been reissued by The British Library as part of their Women Writers series – a series I have come to especially love, it’s just so up my alley.
Mamma is rather different to Guard your Daughters, the central relationships perhaps just nudging the taboo. However, everything is quite held back emotionally, there’s a lot of subtlety which I appreciated. In fact, this novel has much more to say I think about the fifties society it depicts than it does about this potentially scandalous relationship.
The Mamma of the title is Joanna Malling – as the novel opens she has just moved to a new house – and though worn out with the effort, is looking forward to showing it off to her daughter Elizabeth who is coming to visit and help out. A letter has arrived from Elizabeth (often called Libby) which Joanna hadn’t time to read in the move, when she does she is surprised to find her daughter has got engaged to a man Joanna has as yet never met. Libby’s fiancé is a Major in the army, she is just twenty but Steven Pryde is thirty-five – a quite unusually large age gap.
Joanna was widowed when her daughter was a baby and despite thinking she might remarry never did. She is still only forty-one and has decided that really she should now be just quite happy to sink slowly and gracefully into old age. At forty-one!! To us in 2021 that really seems laughable – and yet in this we begin to see the way middle class societal expectations influenced women at this time. Joanna had been living as a widow for a long time, now with her daughter about to marry it was her turn to sink off into obscurity – it was the proper, suitable way of living. These class expectations and contradictions are everywhere in this novel – in the way other friends and relatives are portrayed and most fascinatingly in the way Joanna’s daily woman and her mother are portrayed. Joanna also realises with a shock that her relationship with her daughter will change, once she is a wife.
“But this young man whom Libby loved was, to her mother, more than a stranger. She felt his stolidity to be inimical, and knew that she would always feel it so. To think of Libby kissing him was an embarrassment from which her though recoiled, and it was desolation to realize that henceforth whatever passed between herself and her daughter would, if of interest, be recounted to Steven. From Janet the loyal Libby would keep a secret if asked, but to Steven, now, all her loyalty must be given, and it would be cruel to strain it.”
When Joanna and Steven first meet it’s not an instant success, though the love struck, excited Libby can’t see that. She insists that her husband-to-be comes up with a name to call his soon to be mother-in-law – and Mamma is what is decided upon, although the word is brought out rather awkwardly – Joanna is after all only six years older than Steven. Joanna wants nothing else than for her dear daughter to be happy, and she works hard at getting to know Steven and helping plan for the wedding. Libby of course is a good, young virginal bride, excited about being married, eager to show off her culinary prowess to her intended.
The marriage takes place just six weeks later and while Steven is waiting for a posting abroad the couple are temporarily homeless. With housing shortages in the neighbourhood and Stephen working nearby Libby and Steven move in with Joanna.
There’s the inevitable shifting around trying to accommodate everyone’s needs and Joanna is particularly sensitive to that. However, soon the three have settled into a comfortable routine in the evenings when Steven comes home. Libby – or Elizabeth (sometimes Liz) as Steven calls her is very happy, she is also very young and rather naïve – she makes small, unimportant errors and her mother sees them – and whenever she can she tries to smooth out any ruffles. The problem is that it soon becomes clear to everyone but the new bride that Steven and Joanna have far more in common – they are on the same wavelength, their experiences during the war were not so dissimilar. This rather toe-curling exchange when Elizabeth wants to put some photographs in the drawing room.
“‘Darling,” said Steven, “have you got a morbid craving to see your own face all over your own drawing room?” Elizabeth seemed thoroughly taken aback.” I – I thought you’d want it there!” “But I don’t. I detest big photographs.” “But – but everyone has their photographs in their drawing rooms!” “Do they?” said Steven thoughtlessly. “How extremely suburban!” Elizabeth blushed violently, and Joanna hurried to give her some support, although as it happened she entirely agreed with Steven.’”
Libby had expected to be able to make a few little changes to her man – the curtailing of his moustache for one – and is hurt when her efforts are unrewarded, she fusses over him too much when he is ill and Joanna is upset to see her daughter struggling a little in her new role. However, Joanna and Steven are drawing just a little closer – and Joanna feels it – she worries about it – but can’t switch off her awakened feelings. It has been many years since she felt anything like this and everything she knows about her role is that now is the time to forget anything like that. Joanna adores her daughter first and foremost – and so must wrestle with these unexpected feelings as she becomes more torn between her desires and her loyalty to her daughter.
I loved this novel – and how in a quiet way it says so much about fifties society. I couldn’t help but wonder how a modern writer would have handled this plot – and I suspect it would have all got a bit dramatic and obvious – I prefer Tutton’s handling of it by far.
I think you’re right about the way in which some modern writers would portray this situation – nothing left to readers’ imagination.
Absolutely, I shudder to think of the way the story would develop. I liked Tutton’s subtle handling of things.
This sounds another wonderful addition to the series! I agree it’s better to have a subtle portrayal – so much can be said without spelling everything out, and somehow it seems truer.
You’re right, it does feel much truer, after all real life is often much less dramatic than fiction.
Great post Ali, and you’re so right – this would *not* have been handled so well by a modern author. Tutton writes brilliantly and with subtlety. And I confess I did find Libby gauche and often annoying (as was her brittle and know-it-all friend Janet). Part of me secretly wished Joanne and Stephen would run off together, but neither would have been able to live with the guilt!!!
Thank you glad you enjoyed this one too. Libby was a bit annoying, but I decided it was because she was young. I thought the way it ended was rather nice.
This series always sounds to me like a perfect fit for you! This book looks as though it handles a potentially difficult situation with sympathy and grace.
It’s a wonderful series. The graceful, pared backed handling of the situation in this novel is perfect.
This sounds wonderfully subtle and trusting of the reader.
Yes, I think so, the reader is trusted. I sometimes think some modern writers don’t allow for readers to do the work.
Lovely review, Ali! It’s so hard to give a quick synopsis of this without it sounding much more sensational than it is…
Thank you, it is yes. I do think a modern writer might have sensationalised this too much.
I enjoyed the review very much, particularly as I’ve been waiting to read this novel myself (I now have a copy). The scene in the drawing room, with the photos, was great — it really encapsulates what’s going on with these three characters.
Yes that drawing room scene captures the dynamic perfectly. Glad you have a copy waiting to read, hope you enjoy it.
I loved this one, too, and was so glad to receive it alongside my blog tour copy of “Tension”. It sounded far more scandalous than it read, I agree, and would have been very different today. The expectations of women, esp of a certain age, were so different then, weren’t they.
Absolutely, the expectations placed on women in the 50s seem ridiculous to us, and totally suffocating. I finished reading Tension yesterday.
I enjoyed Guard Your Daughters, especially how the danger in the house really wasn’t mentioned until near the end, but was very clearly destructive. Naivity among the daughters was also rather cringing.
I shall pursue this one. Thank you for your review.
Caroline
Glad you like the sound of this one, I really hope you enjoy it too.
I think I’d like the subtlety and interesting plot of this one, I’ll keep a look out for it.
I’m sure you would appreciate it Grier.
This sounds like a very satisfying read. Although I don’t want photographs all over my drawing room either (and don’t have a drawing room, so nobody need be offended either way, as it turns out) LOL
Ha! Yes it was a very satisfying read.