
With thanks to the publisher for the review copy.
I have written before about my feelings towards Angela Thirkell – how I want to like her more than I do, how I get more than a little irritated by her world view – her snobbery and casual xenophobia. So, I’ll not repeat myself – you can read some of my thoughts about her in my previous posts like Before Lunch, The Headmistress, The Brandons and others, I have now read quite a few Thirkell – like I say I really do want to like her. Growing Up is set in the middle of World War Two – and as many of you know I do like a wartime novel – (written during the period for preference). As it was All Virago All August too – I decided to give dear old Ange another go – and while she will always irritate me I have to say I did really enjoy this one.
Angela Thirkell was a prolific writer, her famous Barsetshire novels number nearly thirty. It would seem that Virago – for reasons best known to themselves I am sure – are publishing these Angela Thirkell novels out of order, and I have certainly not been reading them in order. There are characters in this novel who I am reliably informed appear in earlier novels in a younger and unmarried state – so if you are reading these novels in strict order there may be unwitting spoilers ahead.
Wartime or not Thirkell’s world is still very recognisably her own. Her class conscious snobbery is present – but is less objectionable. Her working class characters less infantilised than in previous novels, though their overflowing love and deference toward their ‘social superiors’ is hilariously unrealistic. I suppose what I would quite like to see – but never will – is a rabble rousing left wing character to come lurching down the village street loudly proclaiming the end of the class system – posting notices of union meetings on the lampposts.
Wartime has brought change to Barsetshire and Beliers Priory is now a convalescent hospital for wounded soldiers. The Priory’s owners: Sir Henry and Lady Waring have moved themselves into the old servants’ quarters – which they are finding surprisingly comfortable and practical.
“Lady Waring sometimes wondered if she ought to be so comfortable, but as Sir Harry worked in town four days a week on matters connected with regimental charities, spent two days hard work on county jobs and was rarely free on Sundays, besides doing a good deal of the gardening, she hoped her comfort would be forgiven, wherever these things are judged, because it made a restful home for her husband.”
The hospital is run competently by Matron – who having lost her cat in an unfortunate shooting incident is given charge of a new kitten Winston – she is very much a cat person and enjoys extolling Winston’s virtues every chance she gets. There are some wonderfully entertaining characters in this novel, from the absurdly emotional Selina Crocket and her mother Nannie Allen to the gamekeeper Jasper who believes his grandmother returns from time to time in the form of a black hare and is determined to shoot her. Laura Morland and Dr Ford pop up when Laura gives a talk for the men at the hospital. Her son, Tony Morland now older and less annoying and in uniform also shows his face, and we see that poor Dr Ford has never really got over his dislike of the young man. Laura finds herself among a large gathering of fans as she comes to deliver her talk – and Matron explains carefully how she got one of the nurses’ uniforms wrong in a previous novel.
“Mrs Morland, in spite of her large and constant public, was always surprised, interested and pleased to hear than anyone had really read her books, though sometimes a little depressed by the way in which her friends lent their copy, to one another, and she took very seriously any technical criticism that came her way.”
The Waring’s niece Leslie arrives for a visit – she has not been well – and very much needs time to recover herself. Having worked in a hush-hush job with the navy she was torpedoed on the way home from America and her nerves are frayed from the experience and overwork. So, when the Warings are asked to house an intelligence officer and his wife, they agree with some reluctance. Their guests turn out to be Lydia and Noel Merton – and with them they bring a breath of fresh air – Lady Waring is soon enjoying Lydia’s company, and Leslie makes a great friend of her. Walking from the station to the Priory upon her arrival, Lydia was delighted to have bumped into another old friend – who is billeted nearby – and soon it seems as if the attentions of almost everyone locally are centred on Beliers Priory in one way or another.
This is a novel written at a time when the outcome of the war was still uncertain – there was still a lot of anxiety about for people with loved ones abroad. Both Leslie and Lydia have brothers serving abroad that they are desperate for news of – and we are reminded of the impact of war with the knowledge that Sir Henry and Lady Waring’s only son was killed in the First World War. Dunkirk is talked about with some reverence – and in the hospital now housed in Beliers Priory there are plenty of reminders of what war can mean. Wartime also brings new opportunities for women – both Lydia and Leslie have benefitted from the chance to do things they never would have done in peacetime. Neither of them really want to be idle – they wish to be useful and busy – and they both have a lot to offer.
Against the backdrop of war and all the uncertainty it brings Thirkell tells a story of a community coming together – a little romance and perhaps just a bit of hope for the future – all being well.
What a strange decision to publish what sounds like a series out of order! Glad to hear this one worked for you.
Yes this worked better for me than some of the others. I really don’t know why they have been published out of order.
I’ve never got past my first Thirkle because I felt very much about it the way you do about all the ones you read. I really want to like her but somehow…. Maybe she’s another one for a snowy winter afternoon, except I think if I put it up against Lissa Evans her deficiencies would show up even more strongly.
She is definitely in that cosy reading bracket, her deficiencies would definitely show up against a modern writer.
I managed two of her novels, but the third sits unread on the shelf, and I can’t see myself opening it in the near future – for the reasons you (and other commenters above) give. A shame, because she has a light touch and tells a story pretty well, and I like the self-deprecating way Laura has about her middle-brow fiction (clearly meant to be a reference to Thirkell herself, so she has a sense of humour). I thought Tony as a child was insufferable, and sided with his mother when she felt murderous towards him!
I think I always saw the child Tony as rather comedic so I didn’t mind him as much as other readers. He is definitely a marmite character. I really like the character of Laura too.
I’ve been reading these for AV/AA but have kept them in order! I, too, thought this was a good one, and I have now got up to ‘Peace Breaks Out’, which I think is a good place to stop as all those aspects that you (and I) dislike are becoming more exaggerated. I’ll see how I feel next August.
I think I will probably only read more of these if I got sent them or someone passed them on to me. Thirkell isn’t someone I go in search of now.
I do agree with you about the snobbishness and deferential working class in her books, but I think the wartime ones are less so, as everybody is working. Still, she is amusing and a good storyteller. If I remember correctly, the first of her wartime novels, Cheerfulness Breaks Out, actually has a left wing teacher who is evacuated with his school to the country, so that might appeal as your next Thirkell!
I liked the wartime element in this, and it’s whet made it appeal to me when Virago sent it. She is amusing though and this one was a nicer one to spend time with.
I’m glad you enjoyed this one, Ali. I never got very far with Thirkell although I understand the escapist appeal – I go to classic crime for the very same thing, and it sometimes has similar issues. I guess I just didn’t click with her style for some reason! 😀
She isn’t the kind of writer I would imagine you getting on with. I probably won’t read more of her now unless I’m sent them.
I love how hope triumphs over experience in your reading of Angela Thirkell. She’s not an author I’ve read or am likely to, but can see why the settings might appeal.
Ha yes, I have definitely kept hoping I would suddenly see her appeal. She has so many fans still. I might have read enough now though, so glad this was more positive and enjoyable.
I’m cheered by your response to this one, particularly as I too have been a bit irritated by the casual racism and snobbery in some of Thirkell’s other books – Christmas at High Rising, in particular. As Michelle Ann has commented above, maybe the wartime ones are a safer bet as everyone just had to get on with it back then, leaving less scope for Thirkell to dwell on those unfortunate views? Anyway, I’m quite tempted to give this one a go, especially as Laura and Tony make appearances. (High Rising I was fine with, but not the Christmas stories – for some reason the xenophobia seemed quite prominent in that collection, more so than it had before…)
I think the wartime setting probably does improve things as everyone works, makes sacrifices or pulls together in some way. High Rising was one I enjoyed too actually.
I really like the sound of this – the wartime setting and the focus on community are big ticks for me. Tony Morland less annoying – can it really be true?!
Yes, he is definitely less annoying although still with that rather bouncy cheerfulness.
Saving this one as I have it but have yet to get to it …
Fair enough. Hope you enjoy it when you get around to it.
I didn’t get further than her first book. It left such little impression I had to go and look up my review to even find what it was about. I didn’t detect much snobbishness in that one but just felt it was insubstantial
Yes, well there isn’t any weight to Angela Thirkell, but that’s not what her readers would read her for. She’s definitely an acquired taste.
I really enjoyed this one, I found it quite poignant but also it lacked the stuff I too dislike in her. I loved Lydia’s development and got very wrapped up in everyone’s lives. Like CDV I’m going to stop at Peace Breaks Out so I have three left to go now. My review’s out today though I finished it a few days ago!
I liked Lydia too, though I haven’t read that other one that she appears in, that preceeds this one. I shall probably only bother with Angela Thirkell if Virago send me them.
One thing that I love about her stories is how they all revolve around Barsetshire, but I haven’t been drawn to continue of late. I’ve still got my old copies of various (not sequenced) novels picked up second-hand, but recently so many other stories have felt more pressing and intriguing. I can see where a new, reading copy would have you second-guessing though. LOL
It’s nice that the books are all set in the same place, with the same characters dropping in and out.