
Fiction that reflects the times in which it was written is so much more interesting for me than historical fiction – there is a resonance which is hard to recreate after the fact. So, this collection of Second World War stories was a perfect read for me. Wave me Goodbye is a superb collection of women’s voices portraying a period that continues to fascinate.
In these stories we see clearly women’s lives and participation in the war. It’s a different role to the male role – often more domestic, those daily struggles to keep everything together. There is humour and pathos in these stories, and together they depict a world of gas masks and shelters, the drama and devastation of being bombed out, the agony of watching a loved one go off to war. With such a range of writers collected together we see a variety of viewpoints too; it is a collection that is a must for any reader interested in women’s writing of this period.
It can be hard to accurately review an anthology of stories, especially with such a range of fascinating writers in one volume. A few of the stories I had read before in other collections, stories like Goodbye Balkan Capital by Barbara Pym, Miss Anstruther’s Letters by Rose Macaulay and Goodbye My Love by Mollie Panter Downes and a few others but it was no struggle to read those again. Alongisde these we have some of the greatest women writers of the period, Olivia Manning, Elizabeth Taylor, Elizabeth Bowen, Margery Sharp, Jean Rhys and Sylvia Townsend Warner among others, a veritable who’s who of women writers. However, I can naturally only really give a flavour of this collection.
The Collection opens with When the Waters came by Rosamond Lehmann. A woman and her children spending the war in the country are shocked when a great thaw comes suddenly in February and floods the village. I couldn’t help but think that this might have been something of how it felt to suddenly find yourself living in a country at war.
“The thaw came in February, not gradually but with violence, overnight. Torrents of brown snow-water poured down from the hills into the valley. By the afternoon, the village street was gone, and in its stead a turbulent flood raced between the cottages.”
At once the familiar landscape altered, disorienting and potentially dangerous.
In The lovely leave by Dorothy Parker a wife anticipates the upcoming leave of her husband. He is due to have twenty-four hours, and she remembers how she had allowed her husband’s previous leave to be spoilt – and is determined to not make the same mistakes.
I really enjoyed The Mysterious Kor by Elizabeth Bowen – which starts in an almost dreamlike fashion, Arthur and his girlfriend Pepita walking together in a London street. Pepita muses about the mysterious Kor – quoting some lines of poetry about a magical seeming place that is far and away from the reality of their lives.
“This war shows we’ve by no means come to the end. If you can blow whole places out of existence, you can blow whole places into it.”
Arthur is on leave and he and Pepita walk back to the flat she shares with Callie – Callie has agreed that Arthur can stay on the sofa while he is in London. Callie welcomes them eagerly with cocoa – happy to experience something of their lives vicariously.
In Night Engagement by Margery Sharp a mother sees the nightly escape into the air raid shelter as the perfect opportunity for her daughter Doris to meet a nice young man. Each day they decide which shelter would be best – later discussing the merits of anyone Doris met the night before. When Doris is trapped under a collapsed building with a young railway worker, Doris’s mother wastes no time in going round to introduce herself to the young man’s mother and the two women begin to make plans as they await the re-emergence of their offspring.
Yet another side to the many domestic difficulties is highlighted in The Sailor’s Wife by Ann Chadwick. A naval wife is desperate to find lodgings for herself her baby and for her husband when he is on leave. She has come to a coastal town where her husband’s ship will dock and leaving her child at the hotel – she walks despondently from house to house around the town practically begging for a place to stay.
As we progress further into the collection, we begin the aspects of the end of the war, and its immediate aftermath.
“A new road, which ran a lane’s length from the farm, was being built by German prisoners, still retained though the war was long over, and from eight in the morning until dusk there was a sound of continuous noisy activity about the moorland farm, as they grey-green figures broke up the stones which were brought in by lorries from the neighbouring stone quarries. The old people, who were called William and Mary Illingworth, had but often seen the prisoners, but had not yet spoken to one of them.”
In The Mandoline by Malachi Whitaker a German prisoner of war is brought to the home of an elderly couple by his guard. The prisoner wants to borrow the couple’s mandoline to play at the camp’s concert. Now, I was mightily confused by a mandoline (not mandolin) and google couldn’t help. Still, the story is a tenderly observed piece and beautifully written.
Altogether this was a quite marvellous collection, and clearly right up my street. Highly recommended for likeminded readers.
Ali, this sounds amazing – I couldn’t stop myself from ordering a copy straight away!
Ooh good, I am delighted. I really hope you enjoy it.
Well, you won’t be surprised to hear that you’ve sold me on this one, too! I’d actually put it on an old wishlist ages ago and had somehow forgotten about it until you mentioned it recently. Anyway, it sounds absolutely marvellous – a combination of some of my favourite writers and others I’ve yet to ‘discover’. Wonderful review as ever, Ali. You really are very bad for my TBR…
It is marvellous, such a great combination of writers. Sorry to be a bad influence. 😉
I have this in a green Virago edition and am really looking forward to reading it. I was even tempted to include it in my Literature and War readalong. Like you, Inprefer stories written at the time to historical fiction.
Oh yes it would be perfect for that challenge. I hadn’t realised it was an original green virago.
It is. One of only a few I have so very cherished.
High praise indeed. 😊
I really agree about reading books that were written about their ‘present’ time. For me this was one of the very strong points of ‘Suite Française’. To get an insight into how people felt about the war while it was still happening, I thought was fascinating. Especially interesting was the attitude towards collaboration, which was entirely different to the way it would be seen by the time the war ended.
Oh yes Suite Francaise was an outstanding novel, a real chronicle of the times.
Lovely review Ali – this really does sound like an excellent collection! Happy to see Dorothy Parker included, and i know that’s one of her stories I’ve read – very bittersweet if I remember correctly. We’ve been talking a bit about Bowen lately and that story is from her Demon Lover collection of wartime stories – absolutely stunning book and if you can read those stories in one block from the complete volume I would recommend it!
Yes I’m not certain but that might have been the first Dorothy Parker story I’ve read. I really must read more Elizabeth Bowen short stories.
This sounds wonderful Ali, what a great collection of really strong writers.
Yes such a strong collection of writers, it was quite a treat.
Refreshing to read stories from the home front perspective. Previously enjoyed the Mollie Panter Downes short stories published by Persephone and Henrietta’s War by Joyce Dennys was fun take on the home front.
Yes, I like stories from the Home Front it gives a different but still important perspective.
I liked this collection also and finally got around to reading it this year (though I had to stop midway through as my puppy got hold of it and did some, erm, trimming of the pages, shall we say? I think my favorite of the stories was the one about the grandmother by Edna Ferber. I noticed she was one of the few American authors in the collection. I read one of her novels in January and really liked it.
I like your approach to reviewing short stories, I never know quite how to post about them, especially when they’re different authors. I have several unread short story collections and I’ve avoided posting about them, but maybe I will try your format.
Thank you, so glad you like my way of reviewing short stories. I must say I do often find it hard.
This sounds like a fascinating collection! Thanks for the introduction!
I’m glad you like the sound of it.
This does sound good, what a great collection of authors and as Karen K says above I’m inspired by your approach to reviewing a collection of stories, I’m never quite sure how to go about it!
Thank you Jane, glad you like the way I approach reviewing short stories. I have to admit I find it quite hard, especially how to get started. 😁
This looks wonderful Ali with a stellar cast of writers! I will be buying this soon.
Yay, glad you’re inspired to read this collection. With such a collection of writers, I’m sure you won’t be disappointed.
Great review! I have read almost all the stories in this book. I would read a story or two between other books. I think i have commented already about how much I prefer reading fiction written at the time of the war rather than books written today about that subject. This compilation is a great introduction for someone just coming to the wonders of Virago, Persephone and Furrowed Middlebrow. It also works in reverse, bringing fabulous short works to those of us who are fans of the great women writers of that time period.
I agree, this collection would be a good introduction to these writers. And for those of us who are already fans of 20th century women writers it holds lots to relish.
I don’t think I knew (or, at least, didn’t remember) that Rosamund Lehmann wrote short stories as well as novels. She’s an author with whom I’d love to spend some serious start-to-stop time. So much to admire and enjoy there.
As for putting women’s experiences of the war front and centre, American writer Marge Piercy’s Gone to Soldiers is a remarkable epic, told from a variety of perspectives. She spent years and years in her research and the publication was delayed for a long while, because she had more she needed to learn. I suspect it would make a fascinating companion to this collection but I wonder how readily it’d be available over the waters, especially as it’s no longer new.
Rosamond Lehmann published one volume of short stories called The Gipsy’s baby, I read it a few years ago. This story is from that collection,which I would also recommend.
Oh, I do have that one: I must have forgotten (or not registered) it being short fiction!
This sounds like a superb collection with so many stellar authors.
Yes, a really excellent collection. Lots of favourite writers in it too which was lovely.
Thanks for this recommendation Ali. My library is trying to restart operations (woo!! So excited!!) by allowing scheduled pick ups of hold items, so I was able to put this in the first batch of books. Really looking forward to reading it.
Ooh brilliant, good news about your library. Hope you enjoy this collection.
[…] On HeavenAli’s blog she recommends this quite marvellous collection in her review in June. […]