
From the moment I started reading this novel I was captivated, sometimes you just know you’re in for a beautiful reading experience. Midwinter was Fiona Melrose’s first novel, and I am fortunate to have her second novel Johannesburg waiting tbr. This is a novel firmly rooted in the Suffolk landscape, a novel of a father and son, grief, guilt and how we find our way home. Beautifully written and deeply heartfelt – I absolutely loved every word.
Landyn and Vale Midwinter; father and son are Suffolk farmers; they live together on the land their family worked before them for generations. Life is very difficult for them struggling to maintain their business in the face of the large corporations. The novel is narrated in alternating chapters by Landyn and Vale.
The two men have remained haunted for years by what happened during Vale’s childhood in Zambia. The family had taken up the call for farmers when things at home had seemed impossible, and Landyn was facing the ruin of his farm. Two years later Cecilia, Landyn’s wife, and Vale’s beloved mother is killed in a horrific incident at the family home in Zambia, and Landyn brought his traumatised son home to Suffolk.
“For ten years I’d shirked the memories. I always felt them scratching at the darker corners of my mind, still feral: but sitting on a tree stump in the gathering dark, all of it – the space, the fear, the sorrow all seemed to find me again. It was if the past ten years I’d only been standing still and I was back in a mess with a boy who only sees ghosts.”
Ten years on, and Vale is now twenty – a decade of grief and anger bottled up inside him threatens to explode – he has taken to blaming his father for everything that happened. While Vale is a ball of fury, his father is a quieter man, a man capable of great kindness, who loves his son desperately but simply can’t reach him. Landyn is never far from his old dog Pup, (warning for dog lovers, old Pup dies rather upsettingly during the course of the book – I feel I have to mention this.) He carries the loss of his wife with him constantly, finding comfort in the land and his animals, and especially the vixen who visits his land and appears to bring a degree of comfort and protection to his life.
“If there’s a night when I am lucky enough to get a glimpse of Cessie in my dreams, I can tell you as sure as day follows night, I’ll see my fox before the next day is out. Even half a look of my vixen and I’ll know it’s her like I know my own heart. I know too without ever asking that it is my fox that has kept blood in my boy’s veins.”
As the novel opens, the beginning of a terrible winter seems to bring things between Landyn and Vale to a head. Following a terrible argument, Vale goes off to find solace in alcohol and his childhood friend Tom. Tom has always been Vale’s best friend, since before the family went to Africa, closer to Vale’s dad than his own drunken, waste of space of a father who is usually absent anyway. As a storm starts to blow up, the two drunken young men decide to take a boat out to where the river meets the sea in a swirling maelstrom of dangerous water. There are consequences for both young men that are destined to last months.
“The water was syrup. Pa always said about boats, to send them out you have to work hard, charting the course and stuff, but for the most part, if you just give it some push, a boat always finds its way home. Same with horses. I didn’t give a shit about horses and I was well past ever wanting to see a boat again. You always hear about the speed of light travelling at this and that, but that night I knew for sure that darkness just stands still.”
The story of what happened in Zambia a decade earlier is told in flashback throughout the novel, and in those snapshots Fiona Melrose beautifully illustrates the confusion of a child who has just lost his mother. So much goes on over a child’s head, and the young Vale’s sorrow and confusion is palpable.
I loved the feeling of landscape in this novel – Fiona Melrose’s descriptions are wonderful and with them we have a feeling of loss that pervades the whole novel. Everything is portrayed so poignantly and with such understanding, as we watch Vale hit rock bottom, hoping that he can find his way back to the father who loves him so much.
This sounds really good – I’m going to get a copy ordered right now!
Oh excellent, hope you enjoy it.
I’m in the reverse situation from you having read (and loved) Johannesburg with Midwinter waiting on the shelves.The idea of a novel which evokes landscape so well is tempting at the moment.Thanks for the warning about Pup.
Glad to hear you enjoyed Johannesburg, I’m looking forward to it.
This sounds excellent despite the brief and rage and regret laced through it. Beautiful review Ali.
It’s beautifully rendered and the grief and anger never get too much I don’t think.
This sounds an excellent read although not one for me, and thank you for the animal upsettingness warning!
No, I don’t its one for you Liz.
Thanks for the warning! I get very upset with books that deal with the deaths of dogs and never ever managed to get past that. However good this book is, I definitely can’t read it.
Well that’s why I put the warning in my review, I know from experience how many readers dislike animal deaths in books.
Sounds like a wonderful read, if full of sadness. I think I would struggle with the animal bit though, but I’m glad you loved it!
I did love it, and the death of the dog didn’t spoil it, though I know lots of people hate animal deaths in novels.
Thank you so much for your ‘lassie alert’…i stopped reading as soon as i read it…u saved me a bit of sorrow today, i appreciate u adding it :o)
Yes, it’s a shame that will put people off what is a beautiful book, but I can understand why it might.
It sounds like place is captured beautifully here Ali, what a gorgeous sounding book!
It is, I’m sure you would appreciate the writing in this one.
I think you pretty much had me with your opening paragraph, Ali. Such a thoughtful review of what sounds like a beautifully-judged book. The characterisation sounds particularly strong – as does the tone or ‘feel’ of the narrative.
The tone of the whole book is just perfect, I think you might appreciate the writing in this one Jacqui.
Lovely review. I have this one on my TBR. I think I need to dig it out.
Oh good, I look forward to hearing what you think about it. Enjoy.
This sounds beautiful. I love the cover too.
I agree about the cover, such a beautifully subtle image.
This does sound terrific, but I think I’ll have to build myself up to read it and thanks for the warning about the dog. Isn’t it fantastic when we’re captured from the very beginning?
It is so wonderful to be captured like that from the start. I don’t usually let things like the dog stop me reading something (unless it’s unbelievable cruelty) but I appreciate a warning.
“Fiona Melrose’s descriptions are wonderful and with them we have a feeling of loss that pervades the whole novel.” And your review is wonderful, too! Such an empathetic description of a novel that sounds empathetic and well worth reading. Thanks for reviewing it.
Glad you like the sound of this novel, it is definitely well worth reading.
Another thanks for the warning about the dog. A pity though, it sounds very good. I wish more reviews would provide such warnings!
It is a lovely book if you can steal yourself to the dog bit.
I sounds amazing but the dog bit – no – can’t read that. I’m very grateful you mentioned it. It’s too bad as the fact that it’s so rooted in landscape appeals a lot.
I do understand, that’s why I included the warning.
I do love that feeling you describe in your opening sentence, where you are aware of yourself tumbling in, confident in the landing. I thought I recognized this book, and I see that it’s on my TBR from awhile ago, but I had an idea it was about something else entirely, so I enjoyed reading your review. Funny how sometimes the reality of one book gets lumped in with your ideas about another book (or sometimes it’s two authors that pair wrongly) and then it’s hard to shake the two apart again. (I’ll be waiting now, to see where the description I thought was this book’s actually fits in.)
I have definitely done that with books before, mixing up different books or titles getting confused in my mind. You obviously added Midwinter to your tbr for some reason so I hope you enjoy it when you get to it.
Im now wondering why on earth this has been lingering on my Kindle app for so long….It sounds a wonderful book. I also have Johannesburg
I think you might enjoy this Karen.
I think I will too