I don’t think I am alone in loving Christmas books, it is one of my seasonal guilty pleasures along with Lindoor chocolates, mince pies and chestnuts.
What is it I wonder about these Christmas stories that bring us back to them again and again? For me I think it’s the chance to return to a simpler time, so many of my personal favourites written in a different era. Other books, perhaps remind us how Christmas can be difficult, fraught with family tensions – it’s nice to know we aren’t alone in finding it tough. Some cosy Christmas reads tease us into believing that the perfect Christmas is achievable in the same way as Christmas movies and those big budget Christmas adverts do, while some show escape from the madness might be the way to go.
So, if you’re looking for some seasonal inspiration for your reading pleasure, I have some recommendations for you – from me – and from others.
Often Christmas is not the focus of an entire novel – but just one part of it. Under the Greenwood Tree (1872) and Little Women (1868) – would feature on my Christmas reads list, they each open at Christmas time. While neither novel is wholly about Christmas, the Christmas scenes are so beautifully written and so evocative that they have stayed with me. Hardy’s depiction of the Mellstock Quire carolling through the village, is simple perfection, it is then on Christmas Eve that Dick the tranters son falls in love with Miss Fancy Day – the relationship which drives the remainder of the novel. Little Women; is twee and preachy I know – but there is something oddly comforting about this old fashioned Victorian novel (I tend to ignore the preachy tone) and when Jo says ‘Christmas won’t be Christmas without any presents’ we feel for her – because however ideologically flawed that statement might be – it is true. When the March girls each receive a book, and take pleasure in reading it slowly to make it last – all book lovers nod in simple agreement – which of us hasn’t done that. Both those novels I feel I have known for years, others I discovered more recently.
Ten days of Christmas by G. B Stern (1950) – Set at Christmas 1946 in a country house. Two sides of a complicated family are gathered for ten days over Christmas. The children: Roddy, Lal, Erica, Terry (a girl) and Clare visiting from America decide to produce a play. They are helped by aspiring theatrical producer Jonathon the 19-year-old Son of the local doctor – who’s sister Judy is also one of the gang rehearsing the play. I read this five years ago – I will definitely re-read it one year, though I doubt it will be this year. I love my old 1950s hardback, but they can be hard to find. I have just learned that this is currently available via kindle in the UK for 99p.
Christmas Pudding by Nancy Mitford (1932) There is in fact something slightly Wodehousian about this society comedy, in which Christmas only plays a very small part. For here we have an impoverished writer, an infamous and enormously popular society beauty in her mid-forties, a young Etonian baronet, a romantic heiress, a devoted couple with a new baby, an eligible, though slightly dull lord and a slightly terrifying mamma who devotes herself to all things hunting. Bright young things, and landed gentry, a world Nancy knew well, and there is just a hint of Mitford’s bitter streak – but naturally it is suffused with humour. I read it two years ago, on Christmas day and Boxing Day – it was an effervescent joy. Not to be taken too seriously – but fun.
The Very Dead of Winter – Mary Hocking (1993) – With the countryside and surrounding woodland deep in snow, a fractured family gather for Christmas at a remote country cottage. The cottage is where sisters Sophia and Florence spent childhood holidays and was once owned by their grandmother. Sophia – who now owns the cottage has not seen Florence in years. Florence her dying husband Konrad and their adult children Nick and Anita gather at Sophia’s cottage for the season and to ease Konrad’s passing. While Florence is dominating and confrontational, Sophia used to living alone, is unorthodox, guarding secrets and managing to keep herself somewhat distanced from the turmoil around her. Not a cosy read, Christmas is something of a backdrop, one reason to bring everyone together. I read this three years ago – 2013 was I think the year I discovered Mary Hocking. (This of course now available as an e-book or print on demand edition from Bello books).
The Visiting Moon by Celia Furse (1956) which I read last year is an autobiographical novel about an eleven-year-old girl’s two week Christmas visit to her grandparents’ house sometime around the mid-nineteenth century. It can be a difficult book to find, and I was fortunate my edition came with gorgeous illustrations.
Some other favourites include: Christmas at Thompson Hall by Anthony Trollope (2014) which I also read last year – one of those gorgeous Penguin Christmas classics, that all look so very collectable. Golden Age mysteries; (who doesn’t like murder at Christmas?) Hercule Poirot’s Christmas (1938) by Agatha Christie and Mystery in White by J. Jefferson Farjeon (1937). Also a surprise read several years ago was The Inn at the Edge of the World (1990) – by Alice Thomas Ellis – “Five strangers gather at Eric’s inn on a remote Hebridean island after he advertises in the London weeklies for “Christmas at the edge of the world.” A really good psychological read.
Recently I asked on Twitter for Christmas reading recommendations, and ended up with a lovely list – which it would only be fair to share.
Some of these were books/stories I had read, some I have heard of, but just haven’t read – but quite a few are completely new to me. A mix of children’s books, adult novels, stories and collections were recommended to me.
A couple of other people shared my love of Christmas Pudding and Christmas at Thompson Hall and other stories.
One title I hadn’t known was; Christmas Day in the Morning by Pearl S Buck – recommended by Robin.
The Story of Holly and Ivy by Rumer Godden – recommended by Kerry, who also loves A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens (also recommended by Amy and me!), The Chalet School, end of term by Antonia Forest, The Tailor of Gloucester, and Jostein Gaarder’s Christmas Mystery.
A Child’s Christmas in Wales by Dylan Thomas (how have I never read this) got a number of mentions, as did The Hogfather by Terry Prachett.
Bellezza recommends a collection – The Everyman Christmas stories which include Dickens, Gogol, Tolstoy and O Henry.
Anbolyn mentioned A Christmas memory by Truman Capote – a story I have wanted to read for a while, I read lots of Capote stories a couple of years ago, but that wasn’t in my collection. I have ordered a little hardback edition of three Capote Christmas stories – though I’m not sure when it will arrive as it was out of stock.
Bagfulofbooks highlights a children’s book called The Box of Delights by John Masefield.
I loved all these recommendations, thanks to everyone who took the time to tweet me – if you have any other Christmas recommendations please let us know.
This year I am looking forward to read Jeanette Winterson’s Christmas Days which I bought recently, and those Capote stories if they come in time. Whatever you read this Christmas – I hope it sparkles for you.
The Very Dead of Winter is a great recommendation. It was my introduction to Mary Hocking, and I hope to go on to read more of her in the future.
Lovely choices, Ali. I have a copy of Mystery in White, so maybe I’ll read it over the holidays. Golden-Age fiction is always a good bet for this time of year.
I ‘m actually reading a Mary Hocking novels now. Mystery in White is good, hope you enjoy it.
There is nothing better to find on a blog than a list of book ideas!
Book People are doing a collection of Christmas books inc. Redbird Christmas by Fannie Flagg – a little book I enjoyed. I blogged about my two Christmas Crime books the other day and I have Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm to enjoy too. My friend always reads “Christmas at Fairacre by Miss Read for a gentle little Christmas book.
Don’t know why my email address has appeared as it has – it’s not mine, but my blog is at “Our quiet life in Suffolk”
Thanks for commenting.
I read A Redbird Christmas several years ago it’s a sweet Christmas novel. Christmas at Cold Comfort Farm is good but only two of the stories are Christmassy. I never could get on with Miss Read.
Some lovely suggestions there Ali! I’ll be indulging in crime this Christmas – a nice mix of Golden Age and Scandinavian. After all those Pilgrimage novels, it’ll be in the mood for a little murder!
Ha yes! A good murder mystery is perfect for Christmas somehow .
A lovely selection of Christmas reading here! I also enjoyed the books of Mary Hocking, what an excellent novelist. Might I add Christmas Crackers by John Julius Norwich to the mix? And my own favourite, An Edwardian Christmas b John S Goodall (a book without words.)
Margaret P
http://www.margaretpowling.com
Thank you I haven’t heard of Christmas Crackers – I will have to look out for it.
What a lovely post! I don’t tend to read Christmas books as such, but I so enjoy curling up with a book on the quiet days between Christmas and New Year, and very often I end up reading one of my top ten books of the year at that time, so it’s a special time for me in that way, instead.
I hope you get a lovely lot of reading in this season. It’s funny how you often read one of your favourite books of the year then.
Ooh, a delectable sounding list. I shall certainly investigate some – I don’t think there are any on your list which i HAVE read, except for Greenwood Tree and Little Women. My guilty additional pleasure will be Hotel Chocolat’s various selector packs. Those containing alcohol may figure highly
Ooh Hotel Chocolat are divine. I hope you get some good reading in this Christmas.
They are my treat to me as I rack up for work related things in Covent Garden about once a month and just have to pay a little stock the cupboard visit. TBH I’d rather go without chocolate than have less than divine, of the variety!
What a wide ranging list–something for everyone I think. Thank you so much for compiling your posts are my go to source for quality enjoyable reads. I loved The Inn At the Edge of the World. This year I have set aside a book I picked up at a library book sale called Village Christmas by Miss Read. It has a 1966 copyright and I’m hoping for a comforting, escapist read.
I also recommend The Birds of the Air by Alice Thomas Ellis,–it’s a short novel set in 1970’s Britain on Christmas Day. My notes say it contains much that is funny and also very sad, poetic, & lyrical yet also sharply acerbic and cutting .
I will look out for The Birds of the Air. It sounds wonderful.
What a wonderful, varied selection you’ve featured! I have a post scheduled for tomorrow about my Christmas reading; luckily we don’t overlap in too many places 🙂 The Capote story is wonderful, and included in the Ecco Book of Christmas Stories if that’s any easier to access. I may just pick up Under the Greenwood Tree over Christmas on your recommendation; it’s been quite a while since I tried a new Hardy. I had hoped to read Winterson’s stories this year, but the review copy I requested never arrived and my library doesn’t have it. Next year!
Thanks. I hope you enjoy Under the Greenwood Tree. I will look out for your Christmas post.
A great selection Ali. Far better than the selection offered up in the bookshop I visited last week which all seemed twee..
Yes many of the modern offerings are twee. That’s the beauty of book blogs.
Wonderful list; thank you for this, Ali. My Christmas reading for this year is already underway but most of these titles are new to me and have been carefully noted for future Christmas delight.
Great, whatever you’re reading this Christmas I hope you enjoy it.
Lovely post Ali – what a fabulous selection of books! A Christmas Carol always makes me festive, but I do want to re-read some children’s fantasy books I read decades ago, The Dark is Rising sequence by Susan Cooper. One of the books is set in the depths of winter and I remember it being very evocative.
Yes I have heard other people talk about Susan Cooper in the past. I had forgotten about those.
Ooh The Dark is Rising is so wonderful – Matthew and I read it over Christmas / New Year one year and had a fabulous time with it.
What a wonderful list…and I think you just started a new tradition for me. 🙂
Ooh good, I love to inspire. 😊
I would like to add that a lovely Mary Hocking novel is Letters from Constance first published in 1991.
Margaret P
Oh yes Letters from Constance is really good.
Christmas Carol is the perfect book to read during the holidays 🙂
It is a perfect Christmas read really isn’t it.
[…] also this wonderful list of Christmas reading suggestions from Heaven […]
I recommend An English Murder by Cyril Hare, a golden age English mystery with country house isolated by snow storm, various people at odds together for the holiday, murder and constitutional law! Published in 1951.
Ah yes I have heard of that one , it’s definitely on my wishlist. I hadn’t been able to find a copy. If I could I would definitely want to read it this year. Thanks for reminding me, I will have another quick look online.
Good news I found a copy and it came today.
Fab list here; I love reading seasonal book recommendations! I always try and read (or reread) a Dickens novel in December – this year I’m going traditional with ‘A Christmas Carol’ 🙂
Ooh lovely. Enjoy that, it is still a wonderful story.
What a great Christmas book list! I have that Trollope on my list. And I love the tree photo.
Thanks Kat, the Trollope is great hope you enjoy it too.
You are right books are great for that period of time !
I Invite also for my posts from Christmas time.
For exaple here you can see Madrid in Christmas period:
https://traveltomeetyourheart.wordpress.com/2017/01/11/lightening-kingdom-madrid-with-christmas-decorations/
Thank you.
I am welcome ! And if you like travels I invite to follow my blog 😀
Thank you for this lovely list. I also remember the March girls and their Mamma and the Mary Hocking I loved.
I should re-read that Hocking.
Also The Mistletoe Murder and Other Stories by PD James
Ah yes, that keeps popping up on my Facebook adverts. I am a bit tempted by it.