Back in December I pledged my intent to bring poetry back into my life. Poetry was something I read much more of in my late teens and early twenties, but it is a habit that I grew out of somewhere along the line. Perhaps because of my own youthful flirtation with poetry part of me associates it with grumpy teenagers wallowing unsociably in back bedrooms.
Back then, still living at home, typically monosyllabic and unimpressed by life, I read Sylvia Plath’s autobiographical novel The Bell Jar, following that up with Johnny Panic and the Bible of Dreams – I may have to revisit these books one day – they made an enormous impression on me at the time. I went on naturally enough to read some of Sylvia Plath’s poetry – I always found it challenging – but there was so much in the imagery of her language that spoke to me back then, that Sylvia Plath has remained somewhere at the back of my mind ever since. A couple of months ago – I treated myself to a lovely little hardback copy of Ariel – I suspect I once had a paperback copy at some time but where these old books disappear to nobody knows.
I am very aware that I haven’t a clue how to review collections of poetry – I have never done so before. Perhaps all I can do is share some of Sylvia’s beautiful imagery – and some of my own thoughts about it.
Ariel; published posthumously in 1965, two years after Plath’s suicide – was her second collection of poetry – and it is deeply personal, often intimate, and frequently challenging. Her themes are those of marriage and motherhood, sexuality, depression, death and suicide. Plath’s poetry is lyrical and though often dark there is a strange luminosity to many of her images.
“The tulips are too excitable, it is winter here.
Look how white everything is, how quiet, how snowed in
I am learning peacefulness, lying by myself quietly
As the light lies on these white walls, this bed, these hands.
I am nobody; I have nothing to do with explosions.
I have given my name and my day-clothes up to the nurses
And my history to the anaesthetist and my body to surgeons.They have propped my head between the pillow and the sheet-cuff
Like an eye between two white lids that will not shut.
Stupid pupil, it has to take everything in.
The nurses pass and pass, they are no trouble,
They pass the way gulls pass inland in their white caps,
Doing things with their hands, one just the same as another,
So it is impossible to tell how many there are”
(from Tulips 1961)
Hospitals feature several times, not surprisingly – and I do love how Plath captures the white, stillness and other worldness of a hospital room. The speaker has yielded her identity to the nurses and doctors, the violent colour of the tulips – presumably a gift – interrupting the white calmness of the hospital environment.
One of her most famous poems ‘Daddy’, with its images of war and holocaust appears an angry railing against her father, a Nazi sympathiser who died when she was a child – scholars apparently differ on just how biographical it is.
“Daddy, I have had to kill you.
You died before I had time ”(From Daddy)
Probably her most famous poem in this collection is Lady Lazarus, a poem I must have read dozens of times in my teens. It is a poem that talks about Plath’s own previous suicide attempts, and her subsequent resurrections, it is also another poem containing images of the holocaust – looking back I find myself a little disturbed at my seventeen year old self’s fascination with it.
“I have done it again.
One year in every ten
I manage it –”
(From Lady Lazarus –
I particularly discovered, how one reads poetry entirely differently to prose – I hadn’t thought about that much before, but it is inevitable though; poetry is such a different art form. I enjoyed dipping in and out of this collection, most of the poems I had to read over and over – allowing the language and the imagery to wash over me. I realise I probably chose a quite challenging collection to begin my renewed poetry reading – but I enjoyed the challenge, although I don’t pretend that I understood completely every word – sometimes I suspect I only gained a vague sense of what lies behind Plath’s words. I have to admit that the title poem Ariel remained a frustrating enigma – despite re-reading it countless times – I looked it up on Wikipedia for some enlightenment – it’s about a horse.
One of my favourites – another one concerned with death – is Edge – it isn’t cheery stuff, although strangely perhaps I don’t find it depressing – but the imagery is perfect, the lines flow into each other effortlessly.
The woman is perfected.
Her deadBody wears the smile of accomplishment,
The illusion of a Greek necessityFlows in the scrolls of her toga,
Her bareFeet seem to be saying:
We have come so far, it is over.
(From Edge -1960)
Sylvia Plath was a complex, intelligent, damaged woman, and this is very much reflected in her poetry.
I only started to ‘get’ poetry when we did the war poets for O level Eng Lit. when the topic was fascinating and the teaching good. Before then, the kinds of collections of cosy poems presented to children left me totally uninterested. I read lots of poems with my children when they were young as they loved the overall sound and would join in, and I still prefer to hear it than read it in my head – so I read it out loud to myself. Poetry, I find, is one of those things that you have to make time and space for and I should try harder to do so more often.
I think poetry does take extra time and effort.
Wonderful review Ali and the reacquaintance with your teenage self in the familiarity and fascination of some of the poems.
Thank you.
“I don’t pretend that I understood completely every word – sometimes I suspect I only gained a vague sense of what lies behind Plath’s words. I have to admit that the title poem Ariel remained a frustrating enigma – despite re-reading it countless times – I looked it up on Wikipedia for some enlightenment – it’s about a horse.”
— I know I WOULD say this, because this is what my research is all about – but what matters most is your reaction to the poem, what you think of it, not what someone says it’s supposed to be about. That might take the pressure off a bit, although obviously it’s only one theory and, humungous hypocrite that I am, I’m about to review “The Edwardians” and shout “Look, that’s Vita what wrote it, in the book”, so who am I to believe?!
Ha ha 🙂 yes I would have predicted you saying that.
One aims to please!
Great review Ali. And I think that we don’t always need to understand every word or nuance of a poem – it’s the emotional response it brings that’s important.
I’m glad you’ve said I’m sure you’re right.
And that’s a better way of saying what I said above!
I remember reading this collection in my early twenties and just loving it. It’s one I really should revisit. This is a lovely review.
Thank you. I think it’s the kind of book one does read in their twenties.
I struggle with reading poetry too, and found your post enormously heartening. It’s very helpful to read someone who is honest about struggling with it and not knowing how to approach writing about it, and then writing so well about it.
I get impatient with myself when I can’t ‘understand’ a poem completely and immediately, so reading kaggsy’s comment is also heartening. 🙂
Yes that’s am opinion that makes me feel better too.
Well done for getting through this collection. I have read The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath it was well worth a read but wasn’t an easy read.
I really must re-read The Bell Jar
Really interesting review – loved the mix of current thought and recollection! This takes me back – I loved this collection when I was younger – fancied myself as a bohemian poet with Gauloise and a fedora – which in Glasgow was a look just inviting a lot of mickey-taking! But apart from looking like an eejit it gave me a love of poetry that’s stayed with me till this day – so a good memory!
Didn’t we all think just like that? 🙂
Sylvia Plath is a great favorite of mine, and I love your inspiring review. It makes me want to open a book of her poems immediately. I loved your approach to this: you DO know how to write about poetry.
Oh thank you.
I know individual poems from this collection rather than the collection as a whole. Reading your review reminds me how important it is to see those individual pieces as part of something bigger and recognising that they may have something more to say when they are read in their original contexts. I must make a practice of reading complete collections more often.
Yes I’m really glad I did that and want to read more whole collections.
I was wondering how best to read a collection on poems. I can’t imagine reading many of them in one go without losing the effect. They deserve more thoughtful reading and much downtime in between each one I would think?
Yes, I usually read a couple in the evening, after laying aside the other book I was reading, often as I’ve said re-reading it a few times. This slim collection lasted me three weeks.
Great review! Thanks.I read The Bell Jar and I wrote about it. It helps to understand some of her poetry.
Thank you, I will certainly re-read it.
I don’t have any idea how to review poetry either, but it seems to me you got it just right discussing the context of the book and the personal way the poems speak to you. Great reading your thoughts on Plath and that cover of Ariel is beautiful.
Thank you. It is a lovely edition, I couldn’t resist it.
Pleased to hear you enjoyed Ariel Ali. I am not a big fan of poetry but perhaps I should be. I recently read The Bell Jar, which I thought was excellent.
I did enjoy it, my book group has just chosen a poetry collection for us to read in May so I should be able to guarantee I’ll read at least one more collection this year.
[…] Ariel by Sylvia Plath […]