I have found it enormously difficult this year to come up with a top 10 books for 2012. I have I think had an especially good reading year. So stealing an idea from Rachel at Booksnob – I have instead come up with a top 12 for 2012. Looking through my list of the 134 books I read this year I see I have read only 20 non-fiction books. Although there were some good ones among them, I have ended up only including fiction books on my top 12, this wasn’t deliberate – and if I had taken my list to a top 15 there would have been a couple of non-fiction on the list – however it felt right – for the sake of brevity at least – to stop at 12. In order to prevent myself filling up my list with Thomas Hardy and Elizabeth Taylor I have only allowed myself one title for each author. Some of the books on my list are re-reads – I find as I get older I re-read far more books – than I ever thought I would when I was younger. For years I would cry “too many books, too many books” when faced with the possibility of re-reading anything. However as time goes on, I find I envy people their first experience of a book I once loved. That first experience of a book can’t be entirely re-created, but it can be enhanced.
I have also created a separate list of three fabulous reads that were published in 2012. I read so many older books these days, Persephone books, Virago Modern Classics, Penguin Classics are among my favourites. I have only read 14 books published in 2012 – so a top 10 would be over kill – however I have listed 3 books which I absolutely loved – and would like to highly recommend. (I have not included Bring up the Bodies or The Lighthouse – which I loved – because everyone else will be talking about them I am sure)
Highly recommended and published this year:
1. The Garden of Evening Mists – Tan Twan Eng – Short listed for the Man Booker Prize – a beautifully written novel set in Malaysia in the years after the Second World War.
2. Tom-All-Alones – Lynn Shepherd A homage to Dickens it is that marvellous thing; just an absolute page turner! – a book to curl up with late at night and read and read till you are done. Also look out for the next book in this series in February – A Treacherous Likeness it too is fantastic read.
3. The Snow Child – Eowen Ivey – Right outside my comfort zone, or at least I thought it would be – based on the Russian fairy story of the same name; this is an atmospheric and memorable read.
So then on to my top 12 books for 2012.
My favourite reads of 2012 – in no particular order:
1. The House of Mirth – Edith Wharton (1905)- Which I think I may have read many many years ago, but had no memory of at all. This started me off on an Edith Wharton binge – I read 3 other Edith Wharton novels this year, loved them all and added a further five to my TBR.
2. Far from the Madding Crowd – Thomas Hardy (1874)– Read for my on-going Thomas Hardy reading project which doesn’t end till April 2014. Another re-read for me, and I loved it far more this second time around. It is a wonderful book, exciting, romantic and still enormously readable.
3. Death of the Heart – Elizabeth Bowen (1938) – Again I think I may have read this many many years ago – before I think I was able to appreciate Elizabeth Bowen’s writing. One of three Elizabeth Bowen novels I read this year, it made me want to read all her novels and I have added another 3 to my TBR.
4. The Garden of Evening Mists – Tan Twan Eng (2012)– the novel I wanted to win this year’s Man Booker Prize, I loved every word. An enormously memorable novel, beautifully written, the images Tan Twan Eng wove into his marvellous narrative have stayed with me.
5. Miss Buncle Married – D E Stevenson (1936)– A Persephone book – and one book I was bereft to finish – I just wanted it to go on. Possibly not as literary as some other works, it is deeply cosy, hugely charming and a book I will read and read again I am sure. It prompted me to order the third “Miss Buncle” from the library – it took six months to come through.
6. A Game of Hide and Seek – Elizabeth Taylor (1951) – Well there had to be an Elizabeth Taylor on the list didn’t there? I have loved so much reading her books this year. A Game of Hide and Seek is now firmly my favourite of her novels.
7. Lady Audley’s Secret – Mary Elizabeth Braddon (1862)– A well-known classic – that I had actually never read. I bought it in the new Penguin English Library edition – and gobbled it up while on holiday – could not put it down.
8. The New House – Lettice Cooper (1936)– A Persephone book, a novel of such beautiful simplicity that it defies description.
9. Manja – Anna Gmeyner –(1938) Yet another Persephone book – a deeply poignant affecting story of five children in Germany in 1930’s during the rise of Nazism. Unforgettable, and unputdownable, a pretty good combination.
10. Little Women – Louisa May Alcott (1868)– Read a couple of days before Christmas, a re-read of course, but I think I enjoyed it far more this time around.
11. Greenbanks – Dorothy Whipple (1932)– I just adore Dorothy Whipple – this was the last of her books published by Persephone that I had left to read. I just loved this story of a family between the wars.
12. Illyrian Spring – Ann Bridge (1935)– Re-issued this year by Daunt books – I ordered it as soon as I heard it was available. I have never been able to afford to travel outside this country – one of my biggest regrets – this novel transported me 1930’s style to sun drenched European villages, I adored it.
So what will 2013 bring? My TBR is at critical mass – and has some truly wonderful looking books on it. There is my month of re-reading to look forward to next month, and the start of the Librarything Virago group’s readalong of Barbara Pym in celebration of her centenary, I know others will be joining in too. I will also continue with the classics club, which I have only recently joined.

I didn’t know there was a sequel to the wonderful Miss Buncle – oh no, another book to balance on top of the tottering piles! I have read quite a few DE Stevenson novels as a result of Persephone republishing Miss B, and I was also lucky enough to attend a tea in her honour in Annabelle’s cafe in Edinburgh, at which her lovely granddaughter told us about her eccentric grandmother (she apparently used to write the books whilst lying on a chaise longue, cigarette holder in hand.)
I haven’t read any of your other choices apart from Little Women and Far From the Madding Crowd, both of which I read as a child so they definitely merit a re-read. Your others sound very enticing (I’ve read some other Elizabeth Taylor and Elizabeth Bowen.) Great to find a fellow reader whose tastes seem similar to mine (I can’t face horror, vampires, dystopia, fantasy, etc & a lot of blogs seem to feature them heavily – my 14 year old daughter reads little else.) I love Persephone – have you read RC Sherriff’s The Fortnight in September? It’s one of my favourite Persephones.
I agree with you about re-reading – I used to do it all the time as a child with time on my hands, then went into the ‘too busy, life’s too short’ mode – but now I have re-read Barbara Pym countless times, and every read reveals more nuances and irony. (I know Persephone refused to re-publish her – I’m glad Virago thought differently, although I do have old copies of all of the novels.) I suppose every time we re-read we bring more life experience (aka age!) to our reading – I loved Excellent Women when I was 25 but I love it even more all these years later. I’ve only now come to appreciate Everard Bone, and I’m sure the same would be true of so many books I read as a teenager. I re-read Great Expectations and Bleak House, which I’d been force-fed at school and loathed, and this time I enjoyed them so much.
Hope this isn’t too long,
Best wishes for 2013,
Rosemary
Not boring at all : )
I have read A Fortnight in September – I loved it. Persephone do publish some lovely books. I hadn’t known they re-fused to re-issue Barbara Pym, how strange – maybe because Persephone are still quite small and bring out only 4 books a year, they wouldn’t have been able to do all 13 so decided on non. Thank goodness for Virago.
A lovely list. I love Fortnight in September, too, by the way.
I’m holding off making my list until later, as I MIGHT finish Daniel Deronda today, in which case that goes in at number one … otherwise it will be automatic number one for 2013!!
I love the idea of a “top 12″ — really, what’s so magic about 10 anyway? And your list is terrific. I’ve read perhaps half of them, and liked them all, so that means the others are sure bets for me.
Happy New Year, Ali!
I love reading these “best of” lists – as Rosemary mentioned above, they tend to include more of my type of book. I have been on the library list for The Garden of Evening Mists for months now – a combination of too few copies and too many readers (the second is a good thing of course). I just read my first book by Lettice Cooper, Fenny, and now I’m looking for more of her books.
Such a wonderful list! Lots I love there. And another reminder that I must finish The Snow Child…
I’m also amused that we read *almost* exactly the same number of books this year – I just trumped you, on 135, but perhaps you’ll finish another one today!
I frequently enjoy the same books that you do. Your numbers 11 and 12 are two of my favorites. I own the Persephone Greenbanks (the only Persephone I own so far) and borrowed the Illyrian Spring from my library within the past two years, I believe. It is on my wish list to own; a used non-Persephone (if I ever spot one) would be fine with me. Like you, I adore Dorothy Whipple, but I can never find her books used and my library system only has a couple of them.
A great list Ali, and so many Persephones in there! I love what you say about re-reading books enhancing the experience of the first read as this is what I have found this year too. I’m finding it hard to pick my favourites of the year, but I will get there eventually I’m sure!
Goodness it is so hard to pick isn’t it. Persephone do publish some lovely books.
Thanks for sharing your list. I’ve read some of these – and look forward to my first E. Taylor. I also love Edith Wharton – you’ve reminded me it’s time to read “House of MIrth”. This year, I’ve read a number of rock/blues bios (a weakness of mine), but also recommend 2 novels, “Good to a Fault” and “The Winter Palace”, thriller: “Phantom” and non-fiction “Tolstoy & the Purple Chair”. Have you seen “Far from the Madding Crowd” – the movie? Julie Christie, Terence Stamp, Alan Bates – the cream of 60′s British actors. Happy Reading, and Happy New Year!
I’ve loved following your Taylor posts and I don’t really know Pym at all so I can’t wait to see those. Here’s to 2013.
I am really looking forward to Pym too.
oh what a wonderful list! we seem to have very similar reading tastes so this list is like getting a box of fine chocolates, I’m going to print it out and search the catalog at the university library where I work to see what ones they have & also make a list for interlibrary loan, also excited to start re-reading some tame gazelle. Hoping to finish on Greenery street tonight. Have a very Happy New Year !
Thank you. I’m glad my list might inspire your reading. Happy New Year.
A wonderful list indeed, I love how reading end of year favourites helps build my own reading intentions for 2013. I read Edith Wharton for the first time in 2012 Ethan Frome and Summer and I’m looking forward to reading a couple more this year, House of Mirth for sure.
The Snow Child was the outstanding read of the year for me, without comparison.
What an interesting list! I am going to put Garden of Evening Mists and Tom All Alones in my virtual shopping basket, I think! I read The Snow Child back in September, and although I loved it at the beginning, it became a bit predictable for me, and I didn’t enjoy it as much as I had hoped I would. I read Greenbanks last Christmas – I liked it, but not as much as the other Whipples I have read – They Knew Mr Knight is my favourite. Little Women I just love. I’ll be joining in with the Barbara Pym read along, look forward to reading your thoughts on Some Tame Gazelle. I have enjoyed reading your blog in 2012, all the best for 2013. Caroline
Thank you glad you will be reading Pym too.